Is Modrinth Servers Good? [Pros & Cons]

Running a Minecraft server has never been easier, especially with modern tools that automate everything from setup to mod installation. Modrinth Servers steps into that space with a clean interface, native integration with Modrinth’s massive mod library, and fast setup times.

But while Modrinth’s hosting is sleek and beginner-friendly, it still feels early in development. With limited regions, no 24/7 support, and few advanced management tools, it’s clear the focus is still on mods first, servers second.

This review breaks down what Modrinth Servers does well and where it struggles.

⏰ 60-Second Summary

Here’s a quick rundown of Modrinth Servers and its Minecraft alternative:

• Modrinth Servers offers a simple, modern interface that’s perfect for beginners.
• You can install mods, modpacks and plugins directly from Modrinth’s library with one click.
• Uses AMD CPUs with DDR5 RAM, ensuring smooth performance for most small-to-medium worlds.
• Allows for basic customization, including UI themes and layouts.
• However, Modrinth lacks core server tools like world management, live player control, and advanced automation.
• Offers only 4 global server locations and no 24/7 support, limiting accessibility for international players.
• WiseHosting, built by Minecraft YouTuber Shulkercraft (2.4M subscribers), delivers one-click everything, deeper automation, modern Pterodactyl panel, and dedicated Minecraft hosting expertise.

Overview of Modrinth as a Minecraft Server Hosting Platform

Modrinth is best known as a hub for Minecraft mods and modpacks, but in 2024 it expanded into server hosting. The idea was simple: make it easier to go from browsing mods to hosting a playable world.

The result is Modrinth Servers, a minimal, modern hosting experience integrated directly with the Modrinth ecosystem.

It’s beautiful, fast, and intuitive but it’s also missing a lot of what makes modern Minecraft hosting powerful.

Easily Start and Manage Your Minecraft Server

Modrinth’s game panel is sleek, minimal, and feels refreshing compared to dated panels like Multicraft.

Navigation makes sense, you can manage settings, start and stop your server, or install mods without jumping between multiple tabs.

Server setup takes around 2 minutes, which is on par with leading Minecraft hosts.

Install Modpacks & Plugins with One Click

Modrinth Servers integrates natively with the Modrinth library, allowing one-click installs for mods, modpacks, and plugins.

However, the limitation is clear — you can’t import or one-click install CurseForge packs such as RLCraft, SkyFactory, or All The Mods. If your community depends on those, you’ll need to upload them manually.

Customize Your Control Panel

Modrinth offers a surprisingly flexible interface for a new platform. You can switch between light and dark themes, change layout views, and adjust how your server list appears.

While purely cosmetic, it makes the panel more personal and pleasant to use.

High-performance hardware

Servers run on AMD CPUs with DDR5 RAM, which means good raw performance for most Minecraft setups.

Lag is minimal, and startup times are fast though the platform’s limited regional data centers (just four worldwide) can affect latency for players outside North America and Europe.

Modrinth Servers Pricing

Modrinth Servers offers four different plans:

• Small 4GB - $12/mo
• Medium 6GB - $18/mo
• Large 8GB - $24/mo
• Custom (up to 48GB RAM)

Their avg. price is $3.00/GB.

⭐ Pros of Modrinth Servers

• Modern, clean dashboard: Beautiful UI that’s easy to navigate.
• Fast setup: Server live in about 2 minutes.
• One-click installs: Direct integration with Modrinth mods and modpacks.
• Solid performance: AMD CPUs + DDR5 RAM keep gameplay smooth.
• Backups included: No paywalls for essential protection.

❌ Cons of Modrinth Servers

• Limited regions: Only four server locations worldwide.
• Missing advanced tools: No world manager, live player manager, or version switcher.
• No 24/7 support: Assistance is limited to set hours.
• Weak knowledge base: At the time of writing this blog, only eight help articles exist.

As one user noted:

Modrinth servers work phenomenally (outside of a few things) but the customer support and knowledgebase is awful.

• No CurseForge support: Only Modrinth mods are installable with one click.
• Not hosting-focused: Hosting feels secondary to the mod library.

Alternative to Modrinth Servers

Modrinth Servers is fresh, fast, and visually stunning but it’s clearly built by mod enthusiasts, not server engineers. It’s a great first step, yet it lacks the polish and depth Minecraft server owners expect.

That’s where WiseHosting comes in.

WiseHosting is one of the fastest and highest-rated Minecraft hosting platforms, offering instant setup, one-click installations, and tools made specifically for Minecraft Java and Bedrock.

It’s built by Shulkercraft (2.4M subscribers), known for the high-quality Minecraft tutorials and technical builds, Shulkercraft built WiseHosting with a simple goal: to redefine Minecraft hosting standards, to make it player-centric.

Let’s compare Modrinth and WiseHosting at a glance:

Deep Minecraft Expertise

WiseHosting isn’t built around mods, it’s built around Minecraft hosting.
Every optimization, support script, and tool is created specifically for Minecraft Java and Bedrock servers.

"After trying other hosting services with mixed but generally negative results, WiseHosting stands out as the most reliable, efficient, and supportive by far. The control panel is responsive and easy to use, and we’ve never once felt like I was fighting the system just to get my server running the way we want it."
– Trustpilot review

One-Click Addons for Everything

Install mods, modpacks, datapacks, or plugins in a single click. WiseHosting’s Addons Hub goes beyond Modrinth integration, it supports all major sources, including CurseForge and custom uploads.

The support team, available tools, tips, overall clarity; all of it is so good. There is very clearly a lot of care placed into WiseHosting as it is. The response time to a server issue I had is incredible. Mods are very easy to add along with mod presets saving loads of time.
– Trustpilot review

100% High-Performance Hardware

WiseHosting runs 100% on AMD Ryzen CPUs, DDR5 RAM, and NVMe SSDs, fine-tuned specifically for Minecraft.

Manage players with Live Player Manager

This is the level of depth Modrinth simply doesn’t have. WiseHosting’s Live Player Manager lets you monitor and manage your players in real time: ban, kick, view inventories, or check Ender Chests instantly, no console commands required.

Quality-of-life utilities built-in

WiseHosting’s panel packs the tools you’d normally find across 10 different websites:

🎨 MOTD Editor — Custom messages with live color preview
📍 Coordinate Converter — Sync positions between worlds
🧮 Enchantment & Resource Calculators — Plan builds easily
🧑‍🎨 Skin Grabber — View and apply skins instantly

..and more!

These all live inside your hosting dashboard, no external tools required.

Game Panel Built for Minecraft

WiseHosting’s custom Pterodactyl control panel looks and feels like a modern game studio dashboard. You get integrated backups, mod management, live analytics, and a real-time player console all in one unified view.

WiseHosting pricing

WiseHosting has on average of $3.25/GB.

WiseHosting: The Only Minecraft Server Hosting Platform You'll Ever Need

Modrinth does a great job bridging players and mods, but WiseHosting’s advantage is focus on hosting. Every inch of its system is purpose-built for Minecraft server, not on being a library of mods or plugins.

In just two years, it’s become the top choice for players who want simplicity, support and Minecraft-tailored experience.

If you’re ready for a modern hosting experience with instant setup, one-click everything, and powerful tools built for Minecraft, WiseHosting is where you should start.